i13.bestScorecardExamplePitfallsFAQAbout

How to Pick the Best Option: A Weighted Scorecard

Independent decision aid · Last reviewed November 2026

Lists of “the best” usually hide how the winner was chosen. This page does the opposite. You name the options, name the criteria that matter to you, say how much each criterion matters, and score each option. The calculator then shows the ranking and how close it is, so the reasoning stays visible and you can change it.

The method is the weighted sum model, a basic technique of multi-criteria decision analysis. A related tool, the decision matrix attributed to the engineer Stuart Pugh, compares options against a baseline instead of scoring them from zero to ten. Both do the same job: they force you to say what you care about before you compare.

Weighted scorecard

CriterionWeight (0–10)

Scores run from 0 (worst) to 10 (best). Leave a row or an option name empty to ignore it.

Method: result = sum(weight × score) ÷ sum(weights), per option, using only the criteria you filled in. The gap between first and second place is shown so you can see whether the lead is real. Everything runs in your browser; nothing is sent or stored.

Worked example

The three options and three criteria below use round example numbers, so you can check the arithmetic by hand. They are not data about real products.

CriterionWeightOption AOption BOption C
Price5869
Quality3694
Support2758
Weighted score107.26.77.3

Option A: (5×8 + 3×6 + 2×7) ÷ 10 = 72 ÷ 10 = 7.2. Option B: (30 + 27 + 10) ÷ 10 = 6.7. Option C: (45 + 12 + 16) ÷ 10 = 7.3. Option C wins by 0.1 points over Option A, which is too small to call. Raise the weight of Quality from 3 to 4 and Option A overtakes Option C; this is exactly the check the scorecard is for.

Where scorecards mislead

Setting weights after you see the scores

If you pick weights to make a favorite win, the scorecard only repeats a decision you already made. Write the weights down first, then score the options.

Counting one thing twice

“Price” and “value for money” overlap. Two correlated criteria give one factor double weight. Merge them or lower their weights.

Skipping the must-haves

A hard requirement, such as a size limit or a needed feature, is a pass/fail test, not a score. Remove any option that fails it before you start scoring; otherwise a high total can hide a deal-breaker.

False precision

A score of 7.3 against 7.2 is not a real difference when each input is a rough judgment. Treat gaps under about half a point as ties and decide on something else, such as risk, cost of switching or a trial period.

Frequently asked questions

How does the scorecard calculate a result?

Each score is multiplied by the weight of its criterion, the products are added, and the sum is divided by the total weight. The result is a weighted average on the same 0 to 10 scale as your scores.

Does a higher score mean an option is objectively best?

No. The result only restates your own weights and scores. If those are wrong, the ranking is wrong. The calculator makes your judgments visible and easy to change.

What if two options score almost the same?

Treat a gap under about half a point as a tie. Change the weights a little and see whether the order flips; if it does, decide on a must-have or on something the scorecard leaves out.

Does this page recommend products?

No. It has no product list, no ratings and no sponsored picks. You supply the options and the numbers.

About this site

i13.best is an independent informational site. It sells nothing, has no accounts and shows no ads. The page explains the weighted sum model, a standard method in multi-criteria decision analysis, and applies it to numbers that you type in. The worked example is arithmetic on invented round numbers. Last reviewed: November 2026. Educational content, not professional advice.